The Borderlands: Culture and Community in the San Luis Valley
By Samantha Lancaster
If you’ve ever traveled through Colorado’s San Luis Valley (SLV), you might have felt a distinct shift in the atmosphere. As Eric Carpio, Chief Community Museum Officer and Director of the Fort Garland Museum & Cultural Center, frequently hears from visitors: “It doesn’t feel like the rest of Colorado here.” And they’re right.
Carpio, who has lived in the valley for over 20 years and has been with History Colorado since 2017, views the region through a “borderlands lens.” The San Luis Valley is a place of shifting boundaries, where indigenous homelands, the northern edge of the Spanish Colonial Empire, Mexican territory, and the expanding United States all intersected.
Read on to take a closer look at the history, culture, folklore, and enduring spirit of the San Luis Valley through the eyes of a local historian.
A Cultural Melting Pot
Long before European or American arrival, the San Luis Valley was a sacred space and homeland to the Ute, Jicarilla Apache, and Navajo peoples. As borders shifted over the centuries, the valley became a unique melting pot of cultures—a blend that is still very much alive today.
Language: The Spanish spoken in Southern Colorado and Northern New Mexico is entirely unique, blending traditional Spanish with Native and Pueblo words.
“You have probably heard, you know, stories or read articles about the dialect or the type of Spanish that is spoken in New Mexico and Southern Colorado is fairly unique, right? You know some people call it like an old version, which is partially true, but it’s also like an outcome of this blending of cultures. The language (spoken in the SLV) kind of embodies the mixing of culture and the blending of people.” -Eric Carpio, Chief Community Museum Officer and Director of the Fort Garland Museum & Cultural Center
Food: The region’s iconic foods—beans, chile, and posole—are deeply grounded in Native agriculture, later adapted by Spanish and American settlers. Even a local staple like the green chile cheeseburger represents a delicious timeline of American, Mexican, and Native convergence.
Communities: Over the decades, the valley has welcomed everyone from early Anglo Protestants and LDS pioneers to Amish populations, Japanese immigrants, and more recent Guatemalan and Mexican communities. “You know all these people from different walks of life come and share space and create new customs, traditions, and ways of being.”
A Common Misconception: Many believe the first settlements in the valley were part of Spanish land grants. In reality, Spain never offered land grants in the SLV. It wasn’t until Mexico gained independence in 1821 that the Mexican government offered the land grants in the 1830s that incentivized permanent settlement.
Surviving and Thriving Together
When asked to name the most important historical figures of the valley, Carpio points not to individuals, but to the communities that braved the region’s harsh, unforgiving climate.
Historically, survival in the SLV required intense collaboration. These collaborations began with the Native & Hispano communities. The earliest Spanish-speaking settlers in the 1830s and 40s could not have survived without the agricultural and survival knowledge passed down from the Native communities already living there. A generation later, early Anglo and LDS communities credited the Spanish-speaking populations with teaching them the agricultural traditions necessary to build permanent homes.
“When you think about how people persevered through that I think it was because of each other right, because you had these strong communities, you had to rely on your family units but you also had to rely on your neighbors in ways that you know we might not have to today or that people in other places maybe didn’t have to and I think that includes neighbors who share the same language and cultural traditions but also there is a reliance of people outside of these communities that created bonds. I think all of those groups of people that really made the valley a home are the groups of people that I admire. They are key and critical in the valley that we have today.”
-Eric Carpio, Chief Community Museum Officer and Director of the Fort Garland Museum & Cultural Center
Even today, in 2026, the wind, drought, and cold can be fierce. It was, and still is, reliance on neighbors that allows residents to thrive in this rural landscape.
Preserving the Past: The Power of a Tortilla
With modernization, there is often a fear that older cultural traditions will fade. Carpio notes that many elders worry the younger generation is losing their connection to the Spanish language or traditional practices like adobe architecture. However, after completing interviews at a local high school, Carpio found that the youth in the valley are interested; they simply need safe spaces and educated leaders and family members to learn from.
A recent initiative at History Colorado perfectly illustrates this. The museum hosted a simple tortilla-making workshop. It was overwhelmingly popular, drawing many locals who had never visited the museum before. Attendees wanted to learn the traditions they remembered from their grandmothers’ kitchens but had felt too embarrassed to ask about at home.
“They felt within their own family and community that they felt it was assumed that there was certain things about their history or culture that they should know, and because it was assumed that they should know it, they were kind embarrassed to ask if they didnt know it, So one of the things that was really powerful when we heard that was we realised that wow, it isn’t that young people aren’t interested, it’s that we have a responsibility as adults and others to create spaces to share and pass on those traditions and I think that is probably true in all of our communities here.”
-Eric Carpio, Chief Community Museum Officer and Director of the Fort Garland Museum & Cultural Center
By meeting people where they are, communities can bridge the generational gap and keep these cultural cornerstones and traditions alive.
“It’s such a special and unique attraction. I don’t know, attraction doesn’t seem like the right word, it’s such a significant and unique site here in the san luis Valley”
-Eric Carpio, Chief Community Museum Officer and Director of the Fort Garland Museum & Cultural Center
Located in San Luis is this unexpected hidden gem. San Luis is Colorado’s oldest town and it actually predates statehood! The Stations of the Cross beautifully embody the spiritual and cultural history of early Hispano settlers. A short, science hike will lead you to view pieces sculpted by internationally renowned local artist Huberto Maestas and the shrine sits atop a mesa offering breathtaking views of the Sangre de Cristo Mountains. Connect to yourself, nature, and others in this unique place.
“Then of course the church on top of the mountain. I think that speaks to everything we love about Colorado. You know you get to the top of the shrine and you have got this really beautiful view of the Valley and the Sangre de Cristos and during the summertime, you know maybe Cuchara River and you see the blue skies and when you’re in that area, whether or not you’re a Catholic or a spiritual person, I think just being in that space you can’t help but to move a person”
-Eric Carpio, Chief Community Museum Officer and Director of the Fort Garland Museum & Cultural Center
The Legend of the Espinosa Brothers
Beyond modern UFO lore, the valley is home to deep-rooted folklore, such as the famous La Llorona, and the historically grounded tale of the Espinosa Brothers.
In the 1860s, as Anglo-American convergence threatened early Hispano settlements, the Espinosa family fought back. After allegedly committing several murders, a bounty was placed on the brothers’ heads. They were eventually tracked down and beheaded by frontiersman Tom Tobin, who brought their heads back to Fort Garland in a gunny sack. Over the years, the story has grown larger than life. Today, it leaves behind a lingering question that reflects the complicated history of the region: “Were the Espinosa brothers ruthless bandits, or freedom fighters protecting their homeland?”
A Year of Celebration
As we look toward the America 250 and Colorado 150 initiatives, the San Luis Valley stands out for its many firsts.
“The Valley is known as being where Colorado began of course a lot of things in the valley are recognized as the oldest, right, the oldest town, oldest grocery store, oldest church, oldest perish, you know either the oldest or the first so I think that’s part of the Valley playing a significant role in Colorado history for lots of reasons. At Ft. Garland, given a lot of the things we have already talked about we are planning to acknowledge the significance and find ways that the valley connects to that history and at the same time using this as an opportunity to remind people that life in a place like the San Luis Valley doesn’t just magically exist in 1876 or 1776 because of the Native Connection to the area and the Hispano settlement in the area predating Statehood and predating nationhood. Those things and their continuation of existence in this space.”
-Eric Carpio, Chief Community Museum Officer and Director of the Fort Garland Museum & Cultural Center
The San Luis Valley is far more than just a historical footnote or a collection of Colorado’s ‘firsts.’ It is a testament to human perseverance and a living, breathing landscape where a borderlands lens brings the past into focus. From the stewardship of the Ute and the resilience of early Hispano settlers, to the modern-day communities continuing to work together against a beautiful but unforgiving climate, the valley embodies an ongoing intersection of diverse peoples. By exploring this rich, complicated history, visitors and locals alike can better appreciate not just where Colorado began, but how the profound spirit of shared needs continues to shape the region today.
The Visit Alamosa Blog
This is where the desert sand redefines beauty and every activity and amusement falls within the extraordinary. Alamosa, Colorado, is more than meets the eye—it’s where limits are yours to push.
